Current filter:
Our District Plan review resulted in 16 appeals to the Environment Court. You can find all the details of these appeals and the results of the court assisted mediation here. We will continue to update this page as the remaining appeals are resolved.
The period for lodging appeals on the Proposed District Plan closed on 7 July 2023, and the period for lodging section 274 notices ended on 31 July 2023. Anyone who made a submission or further submission on the Proposed District Plan had the opportunity to lodge an appeal with the Environment Court in respect of provisions to which their submission referred.
You can find the appeals and section 274 notices received below
On 7 August 2024, the Environment Court issued its decision on amendments to the Proposed District Plan that were agreed through Court-assisted mediation on the appeals. The decision, also known as the consent order, can be found here.
The consent order makes changes to the following sections of the Proposed District Plan:
As a result of the consent order, the following appeals are now fully resolved:
Tukituki Water Security Project & Water Holdings Hawke’s Bay Ltd – ENV-2023-AKL-119
In addition, the following appeal has been withdrawn:
Further Environment Court decisions will be made available on this page as remaining appeals are resolved.
Click on an appellant name from the list below to view appeal documents for that appeal. Council will continue to update these as each appeal progresses through the appeals process.
Submitter Number: S99
Further Submitter Number: n/a
Appeal Status: Resolved
Environment Court Reference: ENV-2023-AKL-000120
Submitter Number: S121
Further Submitter Number: FS25
Appeal Status: Resolved
Environment Court Reference: ENV-2023-AKL-000114
Federated Farmers of New Zealand - Notice of Appeal
s274 First Gas Limited - Federated Farmers v CHBDC
s274 Forest and Bird - Federated Farmers v CHBDC
s274 Horticulture New Zealand - Federated Farmers v CHBDC
s274 Paul Robottom and Pairatahi Holdings Ltd - Forest and Bird v CHBDC & Federated Farmers v CHBDC
Submitter Number: S105
Further Submitter Number: FS4
Appeal Status: Partly resolved
Environment Court Reference: ENV-2023-AKL-000121
James William Bridge - Notice of Appeal
s274 Fire and Emergency New Zealand - James William Bridge v CHBDC
s274 Horticulture New Zealand - James Bridge v CHBDC
s274 Livingston Properties Ltd - James William Bridge v CHBDC
s274 The Trustees of the Havelock Bluff Trust - James William Bridge v CHBDC
Submitter Number: S127
Further Submitter Number: FS27
Appeal Status: Partly resolved
Environment Court Reference: ENV-2023-AKL-000117
Livingston Properties Limited - Notice of Appeal
s274 Federated Farmers New Zealand - Livingston v CHBDC
s274 James William Bridge - Livingston Properties Ltd v CHBDC
Submitter Number: S43
Further Submitter Number: FS14
Appeal Status: Resolved
Environment Court Reference: ENV-2023-AKL-000118
New Zealand Agricultural Aviation Association - Notice of Appeal
Environment Court acknowledgement of appeal - NZAAA
s274 Transpower - NZ Agricultural Aviation Association v CHBDC
Submitter Number: S75
Further Submitter Number: FS9
Appeal Status: Resolved
Environment Court Reference: ENV-2023-AKL-000116
The Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated - Notice of Appeal
s274 Federated Farmers New Zealand - Forest and Bird v CHBDC
s274 Horticulture New Zealand - Forest and Bird v CHBDC
s274 James William Bridge - Forest and Bird v CHBDC
s274 Paul Robottom and Pairatahi Holdings Ltd - Forest and Bird v CHBDC & Federated Farmers v CHBDC
s274 Rayonier Matariki Forests - Forest and Bird v CHBDC
s274 Transpower - Forest and Bird v CHBDC
Submitter Number: S79
Further Submitter Number: FS18
Appeal Status: Resolved
Environment Court Reference: ENV-2023-AKL-000113
Transpower NZ Ltd - Notice of Appeal
Environment Court acknowledgement of appeal - Transpower NZ Ltd
Submitter Number: S109
Further Submitter Number: n/a
Appeal Status: Withdrawn
Environment Court Reference: ENV-2023-AKL-000115
Submitter Number: n/a
Further Submitter Number: FS29 and FS1
Appeal Status: Resolved
Environment Court Reference: ENV-2023-AKL-000119
Water Holdings Hawke's Bay Limited & Tukituki Water Security Project - Notice of Appeal
s274 Forest and Bird - Water Holdings HB Tukituki Water Security Project v CHBDC
s274 Horticulture New Zealand - Water Holdings HB and Tukituki Water Security Project v CHBDC
s274 Trevor LeLievre - Water Holdings HB Tukituki Water Security Project v CHBDC
Here is a list of all section 274 parties that have joined appeal proceedings. Where relevant, the section 274 parties have been listed under the appellants in the drop-down boxes above.
Horticulture New Zealand s274 - Federated Farmers v CHBDC
Horticulture New Zealand s274 - Forest and Bird v CHBDC
Horticulture New Zealand s274 - James Bridge v CHBDC
Horticulture New Zealand s274 - Transpower v CHBDC
Horticulture New Zealand s274 - Water Holdings HB and Tukituki Water Security Project v CHBDC
Disclaimers and Copyright
While every endeavour has been taken by the Central Hawke's Bay District Council to ensure that the information on this website is
accurate and up to date, Central Hawke's Bay District Council shall not be liable for any loss suffered through the use, directly or indirectly, of information on this website. Information contained has been assembled in good faith.
Some of the information available in this site is from the New Zealand Public domain and supplied by relevant
government agencies. Central Hawke's Bay District Council cannot accept any liability for its accuracy or content.
Portions of the information and material on this site, including data, pages, documents, online
graphics and images are protected by copyright, unless specifically notified to the contrary. Externally sourced
information or material is copyright to the respective provider.
© Central Hawke's Bay District Council - / +64 6 857 8060 / customerservice@chbdc.govt.nz